Ancient History Book Review

The Ark Before Noah: Decoding The Story of the Flood by Irving Finkel, 2014, 352pp

The Ark Before Noah is a rather charming history book looks at the pre-biblical Mesopotamian flood myth in all its glory. For those who don't know, the author Irving Finkel is the Assistant Keeper of Ancient Mesopotamian script, languages, and cultures in the Department of the Middle East in the British Museum, and is essentially the museum's curator of cuneiform tablets. It's a position he's held for a very long time, and has a wealth of experience, both as a researcher and as a public speaker in the museum.

This experience contributes significantly to the book. Aside from the core subject matter of the flood story, Finkel give us stories of life in the museum and anecdotes from his own early career as a student and educator. Among these is the story of the first decipherment of the Mesopotamian flood text by George Smith (who was so moved by the discovery he screamed and removed his clothes – just like a Babylonian prophet!). There are also stories of later discoveries volunteer translators and Finkel himself, as well as anecdotes from his own earlier career. These personal touches are a welcome (and vanishingly rare in history books) addition to the story Finkel weaves about the evolution of the flood story.

 

In the audio version, all of this is delivered by Finkel himself in a friendly and conversational manner – he's clearly used to conveying history to a wide audience, and has written several children's books as well as a novel. For gamers – particularly a British gamers – there's an added bonus: Finkel sounds a lot like veteran GM Nigel Clarke, who is himself no stranger to ancient history! So if you ever wondered what it would be like to play in a session GMed by Finkel, play first with Nigel and then give this book a whirl. I haven't played with Nigel myself, but it he breaks role occasionally to tell you stories about his 'cinematically eccentric' colleagues or his flowering from youth to scholar, then the picture will be complete.

“...It was this archaeological fluke that got me the cuneiform job. After signing the official secrets act, I was handed my heavy, pass-port-to-the-nations-treasure key, which is soberly inscribed 'if lost, 20 shillings reward'. The tablet collections in the British Museum defied, and still defy, belief.”

As for the core content, Finkel covers all the basics, giving us the stories of the discovery of the various tablets that reference the flood, their provenance, and their contents, and their relative dates of origin. Of these, two come from the Old Babylonian period, two from the Middle Babylonian Kassite period, two from the Assyrian period, and finally the reference found in the Gilgamesh epic of the Neo Babylonian period. Two tablets are written in Sumerian, the rest are Akkadian.

Finkel also gives us context, describing the relevant bits of Babylonian society, including the idiosyncrasies of writing cuneiform, the role and life of scribes in society, and how writing changed over time. Then he goes through the tablets, spending time on the various episodes to give context to the things described in them. He will ask, for example, what did the ark look like? What kind of boat was it? Then relate what the tablets tell us to what we actually know of ancient Mesopotamian boats. Similarly, he looks at who the flood hero (Atrahasis, Utnapishtim, or Ziusudra, depending on the tablet) might have been, how the god, Enki, conveyed his instructions, and where the boat might have landed afterward.

I started to count off the aspects of Babylonian culture he listed and I compared them to what we included in the Mythic Babylon supplement for Mythras, and soon came to the conclusion that this book offers a nice primer to Babylonian culture. Much of what he talks about is covered in Mythic Babylon, including:

• The writing and delivery of personal correspondence,
• Who the Great Gods were
• The nature of literature and scribal culture,
• The nature of omens (including the reading of birth defects),
• Types of divination such as extispicy and leucanomancy,
• The use of mumbo-jumbo language in spells,
• The Asu and Ashipu as medical specialists,
• Gudu priests and other clergy,
• Dream incubation,
• Reed houses in the southern marsh,
• The shape and use of quppu boats, among others, and
• The source of bitumen for waterproofing.

All of this and more is found in Mythic Babylon.

The Ark was a Quppu boat!

 
Finkel also covers a number of things we didn't include in our text, such as the various places people thought the ark had come to rest (A mountain in Urartu, or Mount Nizir, or even Mt Gudi). He discusses the evolution of the flood myth, and the possibility for a trade in 'ark artifacts' not unlike what happened with the bones of saints and pieces of the 'true cross' in the Middle Ages. He spends quite a bit of time developing his theory that the roots of monotheism are to be found in 7th & 6th Century Babylon. He even included a few little gems to surprise me – such as how people can only write cuneiform right-handed, or that truly good scribes were said to 'follow the mouth', or that Hammurabi's Code was written in a deliberately old fashioned style so it could lean on the weight of tradition. And did you know that the word 'disaster' has its roots in the words 'dire' and 'star'? The Dire Star will be the name of my next Fiasco spaceship!

Obviously, I quite enjoyed the book – both as a history buff and as a gamer. Anytime I read a book and learn something that excites me AND I get something I can use in gaming, I consider that a book well read. If the story is also accessible, well-told, and convincing, then that's a five out of five stars book from my perspective, and one I can recommend to my friends.